Krampus Wins in Court. But is Satanism a Religion?

November 11, 2026

Play Episode
Play Episode

Episode Summary

Welcome to the Napa Legal Podcast, where we discuss religious liberty from the perspective of faith-based nonprofits.In this week’s episode, Frank DeVito is joined by Caleb Bizard, a Catholic University law student and Napa Legal intern, to cover three stories.

First, a federal court in Iowa sided with the Satanic Temple after the state denied it a permit, three years running, for a holiday event in the Iowa State Capitol rotunda. The state’s main reason was that a performer dressed as Krampus, carrying a bundle of sticks, would frighten children. Frank asks whether a group that rejects any creator can be a “religion” under the First Amendment at all.

Second, the Thomas More Society has filed an amicus brief in Isaacson v. State of Arizona, asking the Arizona Court of Appeals to restore informed consent, ultrasound, and waiting period requirements that a Maricopa County judge struck down under the state’s new abortion amendment.

Third, a quick rundown of last week’s state ballot measures on life, marriage, and religious liberty.

Chapter markers

0:00 Intro

0:21 Welcome to the Napa Legal Podcast

1:00 This week’s stories

1:34 The Satanic Temple and the Iowa State Capitol

2:24 Three years of denials over a Krampus costume

3:15 The Satanic Temple and the ACLU sue

3:47 A federal court rules for the Satanic Temple

4:03 The Capitol rotunda as a limited public forum

4:46 Unreasonable and viewpoint-based: why Iowa lost

5:49 The religious exercise claims left unaddressed

6:04 Frank: what “religion” meant to the founders

7:03 The Satanic Temple doesn’t believe in a creator

8:07 IRS 501(c)(3) status is not the First Amendment test

9:01 Free speech and the tiers of scrutiny

9:43 Question one: is this protected speech?

10:38 Blasphemy as a traditional exception to free speech

11:11 Blasphemy and the original meaning of the First Amendment

12:54 Question two: does the state have a compelling interest?

14:12 Frank: the founders would be horrified

14:54 Why the religion question never gets decided

15:35 Rights as means to public goods, not ends in themselves

16:23 Caleb: courts keep sidestepping the definition of religion

17:44 Arizona Right to Life appeals

17:56 Arizona’s abortion amendment and heightened scrutiny

18:25 A judge strikes informed consent, ultrasound, and waiting period laws

18:47 The trial court’s reliance on the Turnaway Study

19:08 The Thomas More Society’s amicus brief

19:42 Contradictions in the Turnaway Study

20:24 Caleb: the amendment’s narrow text

21:35 Informed consent is mainstream medical ethics

22:26 Caleb: how the tiers of scrutiny let judges reach their preferred outcomes

24:00 60% of women turned away were later glad to be pregnant

24:57 Frank: “deny, restrict, or interfere” doesn’t mean “delay”

26:34 State ballot measures from the midterms

27:36 Alabama: Pledge of Allegiance and student-led prayer

28:18 Idaho rejects an abortion rights initiative

29:10 Missouri, Nevada, and Vermont

30:06 Virginia’s abortion and marriage amendments

31:05 Wisconsin: protecting houses of worship during emergencies

31:48 Frank: the pro-life movement’s work on the ground

33:53 Wrap-up

Lawyers: Applications for the Good Counselor Project and Napa Legal’s fellowship for Christian attorneys are open until December 1. Learn more at https://www.napalegalinstitute.org/

For more about Napa Legal and our work, visit our website here:https://www.napalegalinstitute.org/

For more of the Napa Legal Podcast, visit our site here:https://www.napalegalinstitute.org/

The Napa Legal Podcast, November 11, 2026#religiousliberty #freespeech #firstamendment #prolife #satanictemple

‍

Other Episodes