The name of NLI’s blog, And God’s First, is inspired by St. Thomas More, who was convicted of treason and executed by Henry VIII for refusing to take the Oath of Supremacy. More’s witness has inspired people of faith for many centuries, as he stood firmly for the rights of conscience despite pressure from the King.

“On his way to the Tower one of his daughters, named Margaret, pushed through the archers and guards, and held him in her embrace some time without being able to speak. Afterwards More, asking leave of the archers, bade her have patience, for it was God's will, and she had long known the secret of his heart. After going 10 or 12 steps she returned and embraced him again, to which he said nothing, except to bid her pray to God for his soul; and this without tears or change of color. On the Tuesday following he was beheaded in the open space in front of the Tower. A little before his death he asked those present to pray to God for him and he would do the same for them [in the other world.] He then be sought them earnestly to pray to God to give the King good counsel, protesting that he died his faithful servant, and God's first."

The Paris Newsletter Account of More’s Trial and Execution,
August 4, 1535

Is a School Choice Revolution Coming?

Contained in the One Big Beautiful Bill, enacted July 2025, is a provision that was previously called the Educational Choice for Children Act. This provision establishes a federal tax credit scholarship program effective January 1, 2027. The new program is not only a win for taxpayers; nonprofit schools will have doors opened for students who previously may have been out of reach.

Read

The Next Stage in the Fight for Free Exercise of Religion

Carson v Makin, decided in 2022, helped restore the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment to its original meaning. However, Carson did not end discrimination against religious organizations. While many states have now moved away from an outright ban on religious organizations from participating in generally available government programs, an evolving trend is to exclude organizations that hire or provide programming in a “discriminatory” way. These "nondiscrimination" requirements effectively prohibit many religious groups from accessing public welfare programs when they refuse to sacrifice their religious beliefs in order to participate.

Read

Bishop Scharfenberger's Personal Liability Judgement: A Turning Point for Catholic Fiduciary Governance

Less than two weeks before Christmas, a no-turning-back moment occurred for Catholic church leaders. On December 12, 2025, the jury reached its verdict in the Hartshorne and New York Attorney General consolidated actions against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany. The jury found multiple individuals—including two bishops, senior diocesan personnel, and St. Clare’s executives—personally liable for fiduciary breaches connected to the collapse of the St. Clare’s Hospital pension plan, resulting in $54.2 million in compensatory damages, plus statutory interest, owed to the plan’s beneficiaries. The jury’s findings mark a pivotal moment for Catholic institutional governance in the United States and serve as a cautionary lesson for Catholic organizations.

Read

Religious Freedom and the First Amendment: The 9th Circuit May Have Changed the Future of the Church Autonomy Doctrine

Religious freedom has been acknowledged as a fundamental natural right from the beginning of our nation’s history. In interpreting the First Amendment, courts have further developed the implications of this core value. Just days ago, one of the nation’s most influential courts expanded the protections of the Church Autonomy Doctrine by holding that a religious organization can favor co-religionists when making employment decisions, even for staff that are not legally considered “ministers.”

Read

What Directors Need to Know About the Duty of Loyalty

If you work with a faith-based nonprofit, serve on a board of directors, or are thinking of joining a board, you have likely heard that directors have fiduciary duties. These duties (typically the duties of care, loyalty, and obedience) bind directors to uphold certain standards of conduct in their service to the nonprofit organization. This resource will introduce you to the duty of loyalty.

Read

What Directors Need to Know About the Duty of Care

If you work with a faith-based nonprofit, serve on a board of directors, or are thinking of joining a board, you have likely heard that directors have fiduciary duties (typically the duties of care, loyalty, and obedience) that bind directors to uphold certain standards of conduct in their service to the nonprofit organization. This resource will introduce you to the duty of care.

Read

More from And God's First