Episode Summary
Welcome to the Napa Legal Podcast, where we discuss religious liberty from the perspective of faith-based nonprofits.
In this week's episode, Frank DeVito and Kyle Nazareth cover three stories.
First, a pro-abortion activist is suing Students for Life of America president Kristen Hawkins and three of her staff under Texas House Bill 7, the state's new law targeting abortion pill trafficking.
Second, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, joined by the Catholic University of America and the Association of Catholic Colleges and Universities, filed a comment letter on a proposed IRS rule that could strip 501(c)(3) status from private schools with racially discriminatory policies. The bishops support the rule's goal, but warn that its only religious protection sits in the preamble, and that its "solely religious" test would have the IRS deciding how churches define their own membership.
Third, a federal court in Michigan rejected free exercise, RFRA, and church autonomy defenses raised by David Taylor, leader of the Kingdom of God Global Church, who faces forced labor and money laundering charges.
Chapter markers
0:00 Intro
0:26 This week's stories
1:00 Texas House Bill 7 and abortion pill trafficking
1:43 Students for Life orders abortion pills into Texas
2:26 A pro-abortion activist sues Kristen Hawkins
3:33 The Thomas More Society steps in
3:51 Does the plaintiff have standing?
4:34 The statute's purpose exemption
5:45 What House Bill 7 actually covers
6:40 Who the law does not apply to
7:27 Ectopic pregnancy, miscarriage, and pro-life laws
9:13 Why the lawsuit falls apart on the merits
10:37 Kyle: treating children as the damages
11:36 Frank: the damages claim makes no sense
12:37 Purpose and "solely religious" criteria
13:10 The IRS proposed rule on racial nondiscrimination in private schools
14:01 A religious protection only in the preamble
14:52 The bishops' comment letter
16:15 Xavier University of Louisiana and St. Katharine Drexel
16:46 Church autonomy and Our Lady of Guadalupe School v. Morrissey-Berru
17:14 Carson v. Makin and the status-use distinction
18:33 Unequal treatment of parish schools
19:31 What the bishops are asking for
21:04 Kyle: religious liberty is not a government permission slip
23:28 Frank: Bob Jones University v. United States
25:37 A broad and vague catch-all provision
26:50 United States v. Taylor: the Kingdom of God Global Church
27:10 The forced labor allegations
28:46 The court rejects free exercise, RFRA, and church autonomy defenses
29:58 Church autonomy vs. free exercise
30:26 Monasteries, novices, and wage claims
33:45 Where church autonomy ends
35:05 The Huntsman tithing case and Judge Bumatay's concurrence
36:42 Kyle: factual disputes, not theological ones
37:29 Frank: the church's supernatural end and the state's temporal end
39:05 Wrap-up
Lawyers: Applications for the Good Counselor Project and Napa Legal's fellowship for Christian attorneys are open until December 1. Learn more at https://www.napalegalinstitute.org/
For more about Napa Legal and our work, visit our website here:
https://www.napalegalinstitute.org/
For more of the Napa Legal Podcast, visit our site here:
https://www.napalegalinstitute.org/
The Napa Legal Podcast, November 18, 2026
#religiousliberty #prolife #abortion #churchautonomy #firstamendment
.png)
.jpg)
.png)
.png)